Best Midsize SUVs 2024: Top Picks Ranked by Experts

Best Midsize SUVs 2024: Top Picks Ranked by Experts

 

Best Midsize SUV 2024 – Complete Buyer’s Guide, Reviews, and Rankings

Summary

Choosing the best midsize SUV 2024 is more complex and rewarding than ever, with automakers offering models that blend technology, efficiency, practicality, and safety in bold new ways. This comprehensive guide synthesizes expert reviews from Edmunds, Edmunds Top Rated SUV 2025, Carbuyer, NerdWallet, and AutoExpress, critically examining their unique perspectives and coverage gaps. We analyze the top contenders in the US, Canada, and UK, examining hybrid, plug-in, and gas options, and deliver detailed, story-driven reviews, an at-a-glance comparison chart, deep dives into trends and features, real-world data from IIHS and IIHS/Consumer Reports, expert commentary, and tips tailored to diverse buyers. Whether you prioritize family practicality, luxury, towing capability, or environment-friendly commuting, this 2024 midsize SUV buying guide and ranking arms you with everything needed to find your ultimate SUV.

Introduction: Why Midsize SUVs Rule the Road in 2024

The midsize SUV remains the sweet spot of the automotive world, appealing to families, adventurers, and anyone desiring more space and versatility than a sedan but not the size or running costs of a full-size SUV. In 2023, midsize SUVs made up over 48% of new vehicle sales in North America-a trend accelerating into 2024 as more buyers shift from sedans and minivans to vehicles that comfortably seat five to eight, swallow strollers and sports equipment, and offer all-wheel drive and advanced safety techNerdWallet. Midsize models uniquely balance everyday practicality, interior luxury, powertrain diversity, and cost.

Auto experts, including Edmunds, Edmunds Top Rated SUV 2025, Consumer Reports, and NerdWallet, praise the segment for its innovation-hybrid and plug-in midsize SUVs are bridging the gap between conventional and electric, while family-focused models like the Toyota Highlander, Hyundai Palisade, and Kia Telluride set new comfort and safety standards. Meanwhile, UK and European buyers gravitate toward models such as the Skoda Elroq, Hyundai Tucson, and BMW X3, emphasizing efficiency, tech, and urban maneuverabilityCarbuyer.

Key Factors That Matter to SUV Buyers

Space and Family Practicality

Seating Flexibility: Most midsize SUVs offer five seats, with an increasing number incorporating comfortable third-row configurations for seven or even eight passengers. Fold-flat seats and easily accessible third rows are essential for families and road-trippers.

Cargo Space: With the rear seats up, capacities range from 15 to 40 cubic feet; folding them down, some stretch to over 80 (Toyota Grand Highlander, Chevy Traverse, Hyundai Palisade)MotorTrend.

Family Features: ISOFIX/LATCH child seat anchors, wide-opening doors, intuitive folding seats, hidden compartments, wipe-clean surfaces, and rear air vents matter hugely.

Performance & Efficiency

Engine Variety: Buyers can choose between turbocharged four-cylinders, V6s, hybrids, plug-in hybrids (PHEVs), and full electric models. Horsepower and torque vary from the low 200s to well over 350 hp.

Fuel Economy: Hybrid and PHEV models lead here; the Toyota Highlander Hybrid offers 35-36 mpg (combined), and PHEV options like the Mazda CX-90 and Hyundai Santa Fe deliver electric-only range (up to ~40 miles) with total efficiency around 25-80 mpg-e, depending on use casesCarwow.

Towing Capacity: Varies widely; some (e.g., Dodge Durango) can tow up to 8,700 lbs, most hybrids/PHEVs are less capable (3,500-5,000 lbs)TopSpeed.

Safety

Crash-Test Ratings: IIHS “Top Safety Pick+” and NHTSA five-star ratings are gold standards. Standard advanced driver-assist features-AEB, blind-spot monitoring, adaptive cruise, lane keeping-are now normalized for segment leadersConsumer Reports.

Family Safety: Rear-seat protection, all-around visibility, and easy child seat installation are key for buyers with children.

Technology & Infotainment

User Experience: Responsive touchscreens, physical controls, seamless Apple CarPlay/Android Auto, and voice control all influence daily usabilityAutotimesnews.

Advanced Features: Wireless charging, Wi-Fi hotspots, multi-zone climate, digital instrument clusters, and even AI-assistants are available.

Reliability & Running Costs

Proven Engines: Naturally aspirated engines and established hybrid systems, such as Toyota’s, generally show fewer long-term issues than some newer turbocharged setupsTop Car List.

Warranty & Service: Hyundai and Kia (10-year/100,000-mile powertrain) outshine Toyota and Honda for coverage, though resale values and out-of-pocket costs weigh heavily.

Value & Ownership Experience

Starting Price: Midsize SUVs start around $30,000/USD or £30,000/GBP, but luxury or fully-loaded PHEVs can exceed $60,000/£50,000. Top trims add leather, panoramic roofs, and premium sound.

Depreciation, Resale & Insurance: Japanese brands traditionally deliver higher resale and fewer repairs; warranty and cost-of-ownership calculators are essential for full cost transparencyNerdWallet.

Trends and Evolutions in 2024 Midsize SUVs

Hybrid and Electric Proliferation: Nearly every major automaker now fields at least one hybrid mid-size SUV, with several offering plug-in options. In the UK, fully electric models (Skoda Elroq, Tesla Model Y, Hyundai Ioniq 5) are rapidly gaining share, and European emission policies are encouraging the shiftCarbuyer.

Tech-Forward Cabins: Even entry-level trims now feature high-resolution touchscreens, multi-camera parking aids, over-the-air software updates, and robust app integration. Top models (Kia Telluride, Mazda CX-90, Mercedes GLC) push technology and luxury rivaling premium sedans.

Adaptive Utility: Sliding second-row seats, power-folding third rows, configurable cargo floors, and in-floor storage make modern midsize SUVs do double-duty as people-haulers and cargo vans.

Safety as Standard: Safety technology packages such as Toyota Safety Sense and Honda Sensing-once upmarket features-are standard on nearly all serious competitors.

Premiumization of Non-Luxury Brands: Value-focused brands like Hyundai and Kia compete head-to-head with Acura, BMW, and Audi on fit, finish, and features without the same price premium.

How Leading Review Sources Approach the Segment

Edmunds

Strengths: Comprehensive test drives, granular scoring (performance, comfort, interior, tech, value), and detailed spec tables. Broad US-centric coverage, including hybrid and PHEV options, plus straightforward pros and cons.

Weaknesses: Less focus on long-term ownership, real-world reliability, and doesn’t dive deeply into cross-market (Canada/UK) differences.

Coverage Gap: Does not always cover EVs in depth or provide running cost analyses.

Kelley Blue Book (KBB)

Strengths: Strong on value, resale, five-year cost-of-ownership, and consumer data. Applies real pricing information to analyses.

Weaknesses: Less granular on driving impressions; hybrid/EV coverage can lag behind tech-focused outlets.

Coverage Gap: Limited information for UK/Europe models.

AutoExpress & CarBuyer

Strengths: Thorough UK perspective, including unique regional models (Skoda Elroq, Dacia Bigster, Renault Scenic EV). Real-life practicality, subjective ride comfort, and equipment highlights-plus expert, accessible tone.

Weaknesses: Infotainment and drivetrain assessments heavily tailored to UK/Europe (petrol/diesel/hybrid mix) and less relevant for US/Canadian buyers.

Coverage Gap: Less detail on towing, warranty differences, and US-centric hybrid/PHEV models.

NerdWallet

Strengths: Focuses on total cost, loan rates, budgeting for ownership, and the practicalities of buying new vs CPO vs used. Great for financial literacy and cost calculators.

Weaknesses: Not a driving review site-less focus on road impressions, comfort, or subjective feel.

Coverage Gap: Doesn’t deeply analyze parent-friendly features, tech integration, or cross-market details.

Coverage Gaps Identified

Few reviews cover all markets (US, Canada, UK) or provide apples-to-apples direct comparisons for available models, especially for hybrid and PHEV versions.

Plug-in hybrid and full-electric models (especially for the UK/EU) sometimes lack thorough cargo, family, and real-world range testing.

Ownership cost projections in currency other than USD can be hard to compare due to local incentives, tax, and insurance structure variation.

Practical issues (third-row space for adults, car seat fit) often get brief attention.

Less focus on "X factor"-how an SUV feels to live with during routine, sometimes chaotic family life.

Top 10 Midsize SUV Models for 2024 - Reviews, Rankings & Stories

2024 Toyota Highlander / Grand Highlander

The Toyota Highlander remains the default choice for families that value reliability, comfort, and efficiency. The newly introduced Grand Highlander expands this formula with genuinely usable third-row space, addressing a common complaint. Available as a fuel-efficient hybrid (36 mpg combined), it delivers both FWD and AWD options, and its Hybrid Max variant offers 362 hp, matching V6 performance with optional efficiency.

Pros: Legendary reliability, family-friendly cabin, hybrid efficiency, strong resale, loads of safety features. Cons: Hybrids can’t tow as much as gas models (3,500 lbs max), interior design is solid but less stylish than rivals.

"Great efficiency and a cabin full of family-friendly features might not seem exciting, but mention them to any parent, and it'll get their attention."

2024 Honda Passport

A “no-nonsense” SUV beloved by families who want solid V6 power and minimal complexity. With robust AWD, up to 41.2 ft3 cargo room, and a dependable 3.5L engine, it's the adventurer’s Honda. Interior fit-and-finish lags the newest rivals, but ownership satisfaction remains high.

Pros: Proven mechanicals, comfortable seats, rugged but refined ride, above-average reliability. Cons: Pricey at higher trims, infotainment system feels dated, no hybrid option.

2024 Mazda CX-90

Mazda’s newest three-row SUV takes direct aim at luxury rivals, delivering RWD-based handling, available plug-in power, and a premium cabin. The CX-90’s PHEV variant provides 26 miles of electric range, with 323 hp and notable towing ability (up to 5,000 lbs). Passenger and cargo space beat older Mazdas, though the third row remains kid-sized.

Pros: Upscale design, dynamic drive, PHEV and hybrid options, excellent safety tech. Cons: First-year reliability unknown, third row snug for adults, high-end trims can get expensive.

2024 Subaru Outback

With car-like comfort and standard AWD, the Outback is the adventure family’s darling across Northern climates. Ride quality, all-weather grip, and huge cargo capacity (up to 75.7 ft3) set it apart. Base models run a proven 2.5L boxer-4 (28 mpg), while upper trims upgrade to turbo power.

Pros: Standard AWD, high ride and ground clearance, legendary resale and owner satisfaction. Cons: CVT can drone under hard acceleration, infotainment is functional but uninspired, not quite as refined as the segment’s newest entrants.

2024 Hyundai Palisade / Kia Telluride

Sister SUVs that redefined value-for-money in this segment, both boasting cavernous interiors, plush materials, and premium tech for less than luxury prices. Three-row versatility (up to 86.4 ft3 cargo), a 3.8L V6, and warranty peace of mind combine for family-friendly excellence. The Telluride leans outdoorsy, the Palisade a bit more upscale.

Pros: Room for eight, strong safety suite, upscale amenities, high owner satisfaction. Cons: Fuel economy trails four-cylinder/hybrids, some interior controls are fiddly, prices on high trims rival luxury brands.

2024 Ford Explorer

The Explorer delivers V6 or hybrid performance, rear- or all-wheel drive, and true family hauling (up to 7 seats). Strong towing capability and a driver-oriented chassis appeal to active families, though the ride can be firmer and the interior looks more utilitarian than competitors.

Pros: Powerful engines, real towing talent (5,600+ lbs), available hybrid, robust infotainment. Cons: Some plasticky cabin elements, hybrid’s third row tight for adults, cost rises fast with options.

2024 Jeep Grand Cherokee

A perennial favorite for those wanting rugged style and trail credentials with urban comfort. The Grand Cherokee offers a hybrid 4xe plug-in, plush Overland and Summit trims, and a real off-road option. Updated in recent years for a plusher ride and more tech.

Pros: Off-road capable, hybrid powertrain available, plush interior options, great tow ratings. Cons: Small third row on "L" models, pricey at higher trims, complex option structure.

2024 BMW X3

A class-leader in driveability, the latest X3 brings premium interior design, plug-in hybrid efficiency, and top-tier infotainment. UK reviews rank it above Mercedes and Audi rivals for ride quality but note divisive styling and a relatively small bootAutoExpress.

Pros: Fun to drive, strong powertrains, plush cabin, plug-in hybrid option. Cons: Expensive, fiddly controls, warranty doesn’t match Korean rivals.

2024 Skoda Elroq (UK/EU)

Winner of “2025 Mid-size SUV of the Year” in the UK, the all-electric Elroq offers space, clever features, and real-world range, plus value for money unmatched among Euro EVs. With 470 liters boot space and between 232-355 miles WLTP range, it’s a family and fleet favoriteCarbuyer.

Pros: Spacious, efficient, affordable for an EV. Cons: Not available in North America, rear USB only on top trims.

2024 Hyundai Tucson

A workhorse champion in family SUVs, especially in hybrid and PHEV trims. The Tucson pairs bold styling with a spacious, well-built cabin, robust warranty, and award-winning safety/economy. Real-world owners praise its ride and tech-but the PHEV can be pricey and storage space fluctuates by battery typeCarbuyer.

Pros: Tech-rich, efficient hybrid/PHEV, robust value equation. Cons: Some versions ride stiff, PHEV more expensive.

Comparison Table: Key Metrics for Top Midsize SUVs 2024

Expert Commentary

On the Growth of Electrified and Family-Oriented SUVs:

“Hybrid and electric powertrains have gone from luxury outliers to mainstream family choices. In 2024, models like Toyota’s Highlander Hybrid and the electric Skoda Elroq prove you can be green without sacrificing space or utility.”

On Reliability and Long-Term Value:

“For maximum reliability, the Toyota Highlander remains the best overall choice, while the Honda Passport is a strong alternative for those who prefer a naturally aspirated V6.”

On Real-World Ownership:

Families increasingly seek solutions that transition seamlessly between the demands of busy city life and weekend adventures. Vehicles like the Subaru Outback and Mazda CX-90 PHEV are in their element on snowy Canadian mornings as well as summer road trips, while the Hyundai Tucson’s available PHEV drivetrain shines for urban commutes.

Regional Considerations: How US, Canada, and UK Markets Differ

US & Canada: Favor larger vehicles, standard AWD options, and prioritize cargo/family space, towing, and snowy climate capability. Japanese (Toyota, Honda, Subaru) and Korean (Hyundai, Kia) models dominate, with growing acceptance of hybrid/PHEV but EVs are less prevalent outside urban areas.

UK & Europe: Smaller sizes, city maneuverability, and lower emissions are crucial. Diesels are fading; hybrid and pure EV adoption accelerated by tax/incentive policies and ULEZ zones. Skoda, Renault, and BMW models hold prominence. Models often tailored specifically for European roads-smaller third rows, different trim mixes.

Canada: Straddles both markets; AWD features and cold-weather tech crucial, but many US-sold models appear unchanged. Hybrid uptake is strong, especially given fuel cost volatility.

Safety and Reliability

Safety Ratings & Top Performers

According to IIHS and Consumer Reports, these models earned “Top Safety Pick+” or Top Safety Pick status for 2024:

Honda Pilot/Passport, Toyota Highlander/Grand Highlander, Jeep Grand Cherokee, Hyundai Palisade/Santa Fe, Mazda CX-90, Kia Telluride/Sorento, Subaru Ascent/Outback, Volkswagen Atlas

Tesla Model Y and several newer pure EVs (VW ID.4, Hyundai Ioniq 5) also achieved top marks in the UK, especially for pedestrian protection and advanced driver assist.

Safety isn’t just about crash test scores. Rear-seat protection, ease of installing car seats, visibility, and advanced semi-autonomous safety features matter to families-areas where Hyundai, Toyota, and Volvo are noted leadersIIHS.

Reliability and Cost of Ownership

Toyota and Honda rank highest for dependability, lowest maintenance, and highest resale.

Mazda: Rapidly improving reliability (but check for first-year bugs).

Hyundai/Kia: Strong warranty offsets slightly higher depreciation versus Toyota.

European brands like BMW and Audi deliver luxury and tech but can bring costlier repairs.

Subaru is known for mechanical longevity, especially in cold weather.

Technology and Infotainment

Modern midsize SUVs compete fiercely on cabin tech. The following features are now expected or available on top picks:

• Large touchscreens (10-15”): Hyundai/Kia, BMW, Mercedes all feature high-res, customizable displays.
• Responsive Voice Control: Mercedes MBUX, Kia/Hyundai, Tesla set benchmarks.
• Wireless CarPlay/Android Auto: Available across most 2024s.
• Over-the-Air Updates: Now common on Tesla, Ford, VW, Hyundai.
• Safety Tech: 360° cameras, active park assist, semi-autonomous cruise, and emergency auto-braking.

Usability is a key differentiator: some brands (Toyota, Subaru, Honda) retain physical dials and buttons for the climate; others (VW, Tesla) go full touchscreen-which, according to testers, can frustrate on the moveAutotimesnews.

Buying Tips: How to Choose the Best Midsize SUV for You

Prioritize Your Main Needs: Will you regularly use a third row, or is a two-row with more cargo room better? Do you tow, commute, or road-trip?

Consider Powertrain Options: Hybrid and PHEV cost more upfront but may offer significant fuel savings if you do city driving or qualify for incentives.

Test the Tech and Controls: Try before you buy: some infotainment systems are easier and safer to use on the move.

Shop for Safety: Demand advanced driver assistance on the version you choose-often standard, but check if you need to upgrade.

Budget for Total Ownership: Consider depreciation, insurance, tax, and local incentives; not just initial sticker price.

Think About Resale: Mainstream Japanese and Korean models tend to hold value better than most American or European brands (exceptions exist for some luxury).

Check Cargo Flexibility: Does the second row slide? Do seats fold flat for bulky loads? Is the spare wheel easily accessible?

Read Owner Reviews: Forums and owner groups can offer insight into irritations or delights only discovered after months of real-world use.

Regional Availability: Not all models or trims are available in every market-especially hybrids, EVs, and PHEVs.

Take the Family on the Test Drive: If you’re buying for family use, bring the family. Load up the car seats, try the rear door access, and check boot space.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: What is the best all-round midsize SUV for a family of five?
A: In North America, the Toyota Highlander Hybrid blends space, safety, value, and legendary reliability. In the UK, look at the Skoda Kodiaq (hybrid) or Hyundai Tucson (hyb/PHEV).

Q: Which midsize SUV has the best towing capacity?
A: The 2024 Dodge Durango (up to 8,700 lbs), Land Rover Discovery (8,200 lbs), and Jeep Grand Cherokee (6,200+ lbs.) top the list. Most hybrids and PHEVs tow less due to electric drivetrainsTopSpeed.

Q: Are hybrid and plug-in hybrid midsize SUVs worth it?
A: If you commute in urban/city areas, the fuel savings and quiet operation make them a smart buy-especially with incentives. For frequent long-distance/highway driving, compare total costs closely.

Q: What's the most reliable midsize SUV in 2024?
A: Toyota Highlander leads, with Honda Passport and Subaru Outback close behind. Mazda CX-90 shows promise but is a newer design.

Q: What midsize SUV has the best technology features?
A: The 2024 Kia Telluride, Hyundai Palisade, and Mazda CX-90 offer sophisticated infotainment and connectivity. BMW X3 and Mercedes GLC excel in luxury tech; Tesla Model Y leads among EVs.

Q: Which midsize SUVs are best for poor weather/all-wheel drive?
A: Subaru Outback's AWD is legendary. All major rivals (Highlander, Palisade, Telluride, Explorer) offer robust AWD. BMW X3 and Grand Cherokee offer performance-oriented AWD as well.